Standards

Decision-making & authorities

Standard: Company can explain how key decisions are made, who is involved, when matters are escalated, and how the final decision is recorded. The process should support fast operations while making important decisions traceable and understandable for internal and external use

On this page
  1. Practical challenges
  2. 3.1Key decision categories
  3. 3.2Decision authority and approval
  4. 3.3Escalation and high-sensitivity decision
  5. 3.4Exception and urgent decisions
  6. 3.5Decision documentation and evidence
  7. 3.6Governance and review
  8. Situations this standard answers

Practical challenges

O Operational

Decisions are often taken under urgency because of wartime pressure, production needs, customer requests or changing technical requirements

Many decisions are made through chats, calls or informal leadership discussions

The person with the most context or who is available at the moment may take the decision, even if the formal approval route is unclear

S Security

Some decisions involve sensitive projects, customers, locations, technologies or military-related information

Decision records may need to be limited in detail and stored with controlled access

R Regulatory

Export, sanctions, public procurement, dual-use, defence cooperation or controlled technology issues may require or specialist input before a decision is made

RES Resource

Small or fast-growing companies may not have separate approval layers or formal committees or sufficient personnel to fully separate responsibilities for key decisions.

Topics

6 topics, each written at three levels. Each level assumes the one before it.

3.1

Key decision categories

Getting started
  • Identify the main types of decisions that should not be left fully informal
  • Cover at least contracts, significant payments, procurement, supplier or intermediary engagement, export-related activity, sensitive hiring, partnerships, use of donations or support, and exceptions from standard practice
Developing
  • Group key decisions by risk and business impact
  • Identify which decisions can be made at team level and which require management or specialist input
  • Keep the categorisation short and practical
Advancing
  • Maintain a decision map covering routine, significant and high-sensitivity decisions
  • Link decision categories to approval requirements, triggers and record-keeping requirements
  • Review the decision map following significant changes to the company's activities, organisational structure, ownership, partnerships, funding arrangements or operating model
3.2

Decision authority and approval

Getting started
  • Define who initiates, reviews and approves/blocks each key decision category
  • Use existing tools where possible, such as email, task trackers and avoid relying solely on informal discussions for approvals of key decisions.
Developing
  • Define approval logic for the key decision categories
  • Clarify when decisions require input from finance, legal/compliance, security, technical leadership, procurement or export-control specialists
  • Make sure the approval route reflects how the company actually works
  • Where decision authority is influenced by ownership, shareholder arrangements or rights (e.g. voting rights or veto rights), reflect this in the approval structure.
  • Where separation of responsibilities is not feasible, define proportionate alternative safeguards, such as secondary review, management oversight, documented justification or retrospective review, appropriate to the company's size and structure.
Advancing
  • Maintain a practical approval matrix for key business and high-sensitivity decisions
  • Apply it consistently, especially for transactions, export activity, third-party engagement, significant payments and exceptions, while allowing justified deviations where necessary
3.3

Escalation and high-sensitivity decision

Getting started
  • Identify decisions and situations that require enhanced review or before a decision is final because they involve elevated legal, integrity, operational or security risks.
  • At a minimum, include decisions involving defence products, public-sector counterparts, export activity, , complex or unusual payments, unclear ownership, sanctions or adverse media concerns, conflicts of interest, controlled technology, sensitive customers or end users, restricted information, urgent exceptions, or commitments outside normal authority.
  • Highly sensitive decision making requires additional reviews and or approvals, with an accurate record of the final decision.
Developing
  • Define the enhanced review requirements for different categories of high-sensitivity decisions.
  • Define escalation triggers and specify when decisions must be referred to higher management or specialist functions before they may proceed.
  • Record when enhanced review or escalation was applied, who participated and any conditions attached to the final decision in a shot and factual way
Advancing
  • Monitor whether enhanced review and escalation requirements are consistently applied in practice.
  • Analyse instances where required escalation or specialist involvement was bypassed, delayed or not followed.
  • Review escalation triggers and enhanced review requirements after incidents, rejected transactions, partner findings or business changes that affect the company's risk profile or decision-making arrangements
3.4

Exception and urgent decisions

Getting started
  • Identify when a decision represents an exception to normal practice
  • Record the reason for the exception, who approved it and whether follow-up is required
  • Avoid allowing urgent decisions to remain completely undocumented
Developing
  • Maintain a simple exception log for urgent or non-standard decisions
  • Record what was approved, why it was needed, who approved it, how long the exception applies and how it was resolved
  • Review outstanding exceptions to prevent temporary urgency from becoming normal practice
Advancing
  • Maintain a structured approach for urgent and exceptional decisions, including retrospective review where prior approval was not feasible
  • Analyse exception patterns to identify recurring process weaknesses or pressure points
3.5

Decision documentation and evidence

Getting started
  • Record key decisions in a simple form, using existing tools where possible
  • At minimum, record what was decided, who approved it and when
  • Keep information relied on for the decision together with the decision record where it is necessary to explain or evidence the decision avoiding reliance on chats, verbal arrangements and other informal arangements
Developing
  • Record the rationale for key decisions, especially where the decision is sensitive, unusual or
  • Keep relevant supporting information, such as checks performed, approvals received, , follow-up actions relied upon
  • Store records so they can be retrieved by authorised personnel
Advancing
  • Ensure documentation supporting key decisions can be retrieved and shared with authorised external parties when legitimately required
  • Control external disclosure of decision documentation, sharing only information necessary for the specific purpose and consistent with security, confidentiality and contractual requirements
3.6

Governance and review

Getting started
  • Assign one person or function to maintain the company's decision-making framework
  • Define who approves changes to decision categories, approval routes and rules
Developing
  • Review the decision-making framework when significant organisational, operational or regulatory changes occur (e.g., company growth, restructuring, entering new partnerships, launch of export activity, donor or programme funding)
  • Keep a short record of changes to approval authority or escalation arrangements
Advancing
  • Ensure periodic management or board-level review of decision-making practices for key and high-sensitivity decisions
Record where you stand on decision-making & authorities

Situations this standard answers

  1. S1
    A foreign partner asks who owns you

    A foreign defence company wants to partner with you, but before proceeding it asks for information about your ownership, decision-making and business processes. Some of the information has never been formally documented or brought together, and some of it is sensitive but the partner cannot proceed without it.

  2. S2
    A critical part, and no time for checks

    Production could stop unless you buy a critical component from a new supplier immediately. There is no time to complete your usual checks before placing the order, but you know very little about the supplier or where the component comes from.

  3. S3
    A supplier changes their bank account

    A long-standing supplier suddenly asks you to pay a different company into a new bank account. The next delivery is urgent and stopping payment could disrupt production, but you do not know why the arrangement has changed or who is now involved.

  4. S4
    Grown from 20 to 200, still run like 20

    Your company has grown from 20 to 200 people in a short time, but it still operates much as it did when everyone knew each other. Now an important decision needs to be made and several people believe they have authority to approve it, while others are not sure who is actually responsible.

  5. S5
    A founder recommends a company they know

    A founder or senior employee recommends a company they know for an important contract. The company looks suitable and you need to move quickly, but rejecting the recommendation could delay the deal while accepting it without further steps could raise questions about whether the supplier was chosen fairly.

  6. S6
    A production site goes down before delivery

    A critical production site suddenly becomes unavailable just days before an important delivery. Production needs to continue elsewhere, but key equipment, information and personnel are not all available, and some of the usual processes cannot operate as normal, while the delivery deadline remains unchanged.

  7. S7
    A consultant offers to connect you with foreign customers

    You are trying to enter a foreign market and a well-connected consultant offers to arrange introductions to the right customers and officials for a . Without local help the opportunity may be lost, but you do not know exactly what the consultant will do to secure the business.

  8. S8
    A military unit asks for free equipment

    A military unit urgently asks your company to provide equipment free of charge for testing, while a potential customer asks you to cover travel to see a demonstration. Both requests may help legitimate business or operational needs - but where does reasonable support end and an inappropriate benefit begin?

  9. S9
    Law enforcement asks about employee misconduct

    Law enforcement contacts your company about suspected misconduct involving your employee and asks how the company handled the issue. You need to respond quickly, but information is scattered, some of it is sensitive, and decisions made months earlier were not all formally recorded.

  10. S11
    Proceed today, or lose the delivery

    A major customer says an urgent delivery may be lost unless you proceed today, but one of the company's required checks or approvals is still outstanding. A senior manager tells the team to “sort out the paperwork later.” Do you delay the delivery or proceed without the usual control?